Murder Tribunal Quest in Baldur's Gate 3: A Moral Dilemma

The Murder Tribunal quest in Baldur's Gate 3 is a pivotal moment in the game's third act. After investigating several murders and saving potential victims, players must descend to the Temple of Bhaal, where they'll encounter the game's main antagonist, Sarevok Anchev.

Meeting Sarevok Anchev

Sarevok's presence is commanding and intimidating, and he presents the player with a final request: kill Investigator Valeria, a quirky hollyphant with a monocle. This encounter is a turning point in the quest, and players must decide how to proceed.

Killing Valeria: The Path of Least Resistance

To earn the title of Unholy Assassin, players must kill Valeria in the Sacrificial Chamber. This approach requires no boss fight and grants the player Sarevok's respect. However, this decision comes with a moral cost, as Valeria is a humorous and endearing character.

Screenshot: Sacrificial Chamber in the Temple of Bhaal (Source: Zotpad)

The Alternative: Killing Sarevok Anchev

Refusing to kill Valeria means standing up against Sarevok, sacrificing the title of Unholy Assassin. This decision triggers a battle against Sarevok and the tribunal of Echoes. While this battle is relatively easy, it's a significant moment in the game's storyline. If the player emerges victorious, Sarevok's corpse yields valuable loot, including his Sword of Chaos and Horned Helmet.

The Benefits of Killing Sarevok

Engage in a rewarding boss fight.
Add Valeria as an ally in the Gather Your Allies quest.
Acquire Sarevok's powerful loot, including his Sword of Chaos.

Should You Kill Valeria or Sarevok?

The decision to kill Valeria or Sarevok ultimately depends on the player's approach to the game. Both choices lead to similar outcomes, but killing Sarevok offers a more rewarding experience and valuable loot.

Killing Sarevok leads to a more rewarding outcome and is the path we'd recommend for players looking to engage in a challenging boss fight and acquire powerful loot.

However, killing Valeria is a viable option for players who value roleplaying an evil character or simply want to progress through the game quickly. Ultimately, the choice is up to the player, and both decisions have their consequences.

Related: How to Complete Rescue Orin's Victim in BG3